S4F3

I just got the final estimate on my little fender-bender. Total was like $4000. The insurance is picking it up.

I noticed that the hood and the right quarter panel which were bent slightly, was being repaired.. and not replaced.

Do you think I can argue for them to replace it? Do you think after a repair, these parts will be as good as new? Anyone have any similar experiences or comments?

Kent L

Replace. Repair will be "like new" but it is never the same.

Amnizu

If it is damaged beyond repair to OEM specs then they will replace.

fairenough

Was there a lot of real structural damage (e.g. weight bearing support beams, signficant engine damage, etc), or was it just cosmetic (e.g. bodyshops can fix misaligned and bent panels easily)? My S4 has already been in one fender bender, been stolen/recoverd after another, and then vandalized (minor damage) and it's still going STRONG. No way would the insurance company total the car and give me enough to get another comparable S4. Don't believe some of the hype here on AudiWorld that if your car has even the slightest damage that it'll "never be the same". These cars are, for the most part, very rugged and will serve you well if repaired and maintained properly. Don't get me wrong, I tend to be a purist/perfectionist too and I can spend a whole day detailing my car, but I'm not made of money and can't buy a new car every year or put $20K into mods like some people on the board (not a rip...hey, more power to 'em). In any case good luck.

DYOS4

Replace. That way it will be new not "just like new"

S42002

It might even wind up cheaper then fixing the hood! Unless there was serious damage to the quarter panel I wouldn't replace it since it would require welding a new one into place.