rapcomm

I've combed the archives for any allroad feedback on these and honestly there was limited feedback in any forum. They're ranked third on TireRack's survey in the high-performance all-season and seem very reasonably priced at $113.

I'm pretty set on the beefier 235/55/R17 on my stock dual spokes, so this ruled out many other tires frequently mentioned here. Looking for feedback on this rubber and and any other 235s (besides the GY Eagle F1 which has good reviews here, so-so reviews--especially in the snow--at TireRack).

These will be true all-seasons for me... one set, all seasons.

Benallroad

I found them to be good but very noisy and not that good in wet or light snow. By contrast the Michelin Primacy MXV4 are super quiet, great in rain and with the $80 Costco coupon (my local dealer matched) I got them for about $150 installed (with balance and road hazard). The other tire I considered was Cooper Tire's new CS4 Touring but the pricing was about the same as Mich.