sIcAoNe

I have owned a B6 S4 and loved it. On the fence between getting a new 2010 S5 or 2008 S5. Has anybody driven both that can give me their opinions? Or opinions in general about the two cars on which is better. I love drining and love performance. I also own a 2001 Porsche.

snow day

Driven both. Assuming the convenience of rear doors is not a factor, the only plus for the RS4 is it feels (and is) a little quicker and firmer. The S5 is way more sexy inside and out. Best choice for you depends on what's important to you.

adansirs5

haveing owned an rs4 for more than 1 year, and have been in a S5 for the better part of 10 months, I have to say overall that the 5 is a more pleaseing expearience, Overall, More so now that the car is equiped with a AWE exhaust with downpipe, and a stassis race suspension system.Wicked doesn,t come close to how this car is now, All i can say is WOW, Oh did i tell you how massively sexy it is?, well let me just say that the chicks really dig this car.

Le Chef

Since you already have a sports car in the 996 I suggest you get a v.quick practical car in the shape of the RS4.

Phantom RS

I just made the same choice a couple of weeks ago and went with RS4. You can get a 2007 with less than 15k miles in the mid $40's. It's hard to argue with that value. The S5 is a beautiful sexy nimble cougar, while the RS4 is more of a velociraptor. More brutal looking and more deadly as well. It is a question of preference. Both are great cars.

yogregb

plus there is alot more pre-owned rs4's avail right now,in so cal,at least
great sig pic! classy photography phantom RS

Phantom RS

Thanks!