View Full Version : The New A6: My Review


AnimaTTor
10-18-2004, 05:10 PM
I just drive the new A6, and in the rain no less (it hasn't rained in months here in LA). Here are my impressions:

Vehicle Description:

2005 A6 (C6) 4.2 quattro. Black ext/Beige Int. Standard suspension. Standard seats. No cold weather.

Design

The outside is flawless. Although I admire the previous generation's clean, Bauhaus lines, it looks dull and dated when sitting next to the new A6. The new `trapezoidal single frame grill' is the best part of the design. It looks smaller in real life, and is perfectly proportioned to the rest of the car. The new grill is also considerably cooler looking than the old split grill. Although busier than the previous gen, the new A6's rear looks modern and clean in real life. Again, it actually looks better than the C5, thanks to gently sweeping curves and sharp creases. The profile was rather ordinary, but that could be blamed on the black color, which always obscures any car's shape.

The inside was the big surprise. I sat both in the passenger and driver's seats. The dynamic sloping lines of the wood trim are absolutely stunning in real life. The dash is pure Audi taken to the next level. The lack of wood trim within the driver's area, while looking strange in photos, makes perfect sense in real life. It's telling the driver, "This area is reserved for high-tech control and performance". I was smitten by how the dash angled toward the driver. I felt strangely empowered. Nevertheless, I had no problem getting access to MMI and climate control as a passenger. The interior is an ergonomic triumph. It also oozes refinement and luxury. Even the dials are significantly upgraded from previous gen Audis, particularly the black dials with silver trim. The interior's quality easily surpasses my A4 Cabriolet's cockpit, which is saying a lot. I also played a bit with the MMI. I grasped it right away. No learning curve issue there.

Performance

The Servotronic steering wheel was another surprise. At a standstill the wheel moved so freely and lightly, it almost felt like it was broken. I'm surprised I liked the feel since I hate light steering settings. But as the speed increased, so did the steering wheel's resistance. I loved it, and got used to this new way of steering quickly. It was hard going back to my Cabriolet's linear steering feel after the A6.

This is the first time I've played with an Audi Tiptronic since my old 2000 A4. The gear-shifting response has improved dramatically, especially when shifting manually. Not surprisingly, there's still a slight torque converter lag when punching power from standstill; although it's been considerably reduced from previous models. Acceleration was unusually smooth for a conventional Automatic; almost as good as my own Multitronic transmission. Power delivery is strong and generous, but not breathtaking. The C6 RS6 will take care of that. Because of rush hour traffic I didn't have a chance to test the V8's mid-range power at higher speeds, which is where I'm sure the engine would have shined.

Another surprise was the suspension. Even without the sport suspension it was tuned toward the dynamic. I definitely felt the road, but the sharper bumps were of course blanketed, only less than I would have expected. The chassis' impressive rigidity eliminated any vibrations. The A6's dynamics felt more like an A4 than a 5 person luxury boat. This is an important point, since it demonstrates just what a solid, well built car the new Audi is. Personally I loved it's nimble, sporty feel. I would imagine more conservative buyers would find it a touch rough. For them I would recommend Mercedes Benz, or a Buick.

In the rainy, oil-slicked roads of LA, I accelerated hard a couple of times and there was absolutely no wheel spin. No surprise there.

Conclusion

Overall, the new A6 achieves a masterful balance between modern design, high performance, practicality, and luxury.

After the test drive, I walked over to a previous gen A6 4.2 and looked inside. The old Audi's interior looked embarrassingly antiquated and dull in comparison. I don't mean to knock the C5 A6, since it set high quality standards back in its day, but the new A6 is a vast improvement in every way.

I smell a blockbuster.

Addendum Note: The A6 was fitted with 18" wheels (the smallest profile tires offered), which significantly contributed to the rougher ride.

GusTA
10-19-2004, 06:20 AM
Great review! I just test drove one as well, and I am befuddled as to how pictures can impart such different impressions compared to actual real-life experience. It looked gorgeous. It was a great car to drive!

I have a 2004 A8L, and other than the lack of adaptive air suspension in the A6, there is no major difference in interior appointments or ride (on smooth surfaces). In fact there are MORE features in the A6 - keyless entry, electrically-controlled glove compartment, compass-in-rearview mirror and so on.

My wife has a 2000 A6. Quite honestly, the C6 is not in the same league.

AutobahnRacer
10-19-2004, 07:42 AM

LIY
10-19-2004, 08:17 AM
I quite agree with all essential points raised by anim8or in this excellent review. Having driven the new A6 yesterday, I was mightily impressed. Regrettably,the 4.2 is out of my league, and I await the 3.2 for comparison with the new Acura RL (also driven yesterday - thought I would like it more than I did).

For background,I currently own a '99 A6 2.8, my wife replaced her 2000 A4, 2.8 sport with an '04 Audi Cab 3.0, q. Prior those vehicles, we were solidly Acura - two Legends and a TL.

LIY

GusTA
10-19-2004, 08:48 AM

Quattrings
10-19-2004, 10:06 AM

AutobahnRacer
10-19-2004, 10:34 AM

AsKmE
10-19-2004, 10:36 AM

LIY
10-19-2004, 12:24 PM
Essentially, I felt the Acura's electronics, stereo, voice activated nav, etc. were superior to Audi's - but, the Audi was far superior by way of driveability (I know, very subjective), ability to corner - better feel for the road.

I likened it on the Edmund's Acura forum to the difference between driving a BMW (more akin to current Audi) and a large Mercedes [or Lexus] (more akin to the current Acura). Also, (and this I found quite confounding), the Acura has no seat height adjustment, which would not be accepted too terribly well by my wife. Also, [and this compared to the Audi V8, 4.2, NOT the still unavailable 3.2) I found the Acura to be somewhat underpowered. Most certainly did not feel like I was driving a 300 hp automobile. Of lesser importance [to me], Acura trunk is smaller, as is back seat leg room.

Nor was I wowed by the interior of the Acura - found the blue display to be a little off-putting, although quite clear; and the silver center console left me with a distinctly plasticy feel (although I understand that the material is actually some type of metal).

IMHO!!!

LIY

Audi S5 TC
10-19-2004, 05:28 PM
I heard possibly later in MY2005 or for MY2006 according to April/Verdegrrl whom I believe got this info directly from Germany.

Audi S5 TC
10-19-2004, 05:34 PM
I believe A8's air suspension is manufactured by either ZF, Bosch or some other very expensive German manufacturer. New A6's air suspension will be manufactured by Sachs, which is a division of General Motors. Although Sachs is American owned, the new A6's air suspension will be German made. The reason the new A6's air suspension will be manufactured by Sachs instead of the manufacturer that manufactures the A8's air suspension is to keep the cost of the air suspension option on the new A6 relatively reasonable ($1,000 instead of $1,500 or $2,000).

JerryS4
10-19-2004, 05:38 PM
As a '97 BMW540 owner, I was also looking at buying either the A6 or the RL and drove both twice. I am going to go with the Audi A6. Why? It has been good to agonize about this for a week and the conclusion is that the looks of the Audi are flawless while the RL has become less balanced looking. I do not like the RL's wheels, the tail and the chrome grill and trunk accents. Too Japanese looking; reminds me of a Camry at certain angles. Although I think the RL has enough power, excellent electronics, stereo and AWD, it is not as good as the A6. I ordered the Black A6 with Ameretto leather interior and it will blow away the RL's parchment interior. The A6's looks are stunning at all angles and the 18" wheels are BEUTIFUL. Even the side & rear lighting are clearly better. No need to talk about the superior 4.2L. The trunk and folding rear seats and several other features not available on the RL sealed the deal. Also, I was not able to get the RLs SH-AWD to bias the power to one real wheel during hard acceleration /turning so this may be a feature that is not readily usable? I could be way off on that one.

BTW, the new 5 series is UGLY and I am not old enough to drive the Benz yet.

trops
10-20-2004, 10:27 PM
<ul><li><a href="http://www.geocities.com/canadacraig/CARS.html">http://www.geocities.com/canadacraig/CARS.html</a></li></ul>

fkess
11-02-2004, 05:39 PM
Do you get a coupon when you buy it to send in for the two missing gauges (oil temp and voltage)? Are there at least idiot lights? Historically with idiot lights, the damage is done when they light up. Why did they do that?